A Teacher Speaks Out: The Dangers of Over-Managing Our Kids
Thursday, March 1st, 2012By Daniel Jordan
Director
Sunshine Coast Health Center
Barb Struch is a long-time high school teacher residing in Powell River, British Columbia. Barb and I both share a concern about the way schools and families are preparing youth for adulthood, albeit from different perspectives based on our professions. Barb has written a poem to highlight some of the dangers she sees in modern parenting:
What a Child Would Say If He Only Knew
by Barbara Struch, B.Ed., M.Ed.
When you tell me that I cannot fail, you are setting me up for failure. So, when
I actually fail for the first time, I will blame anybody else because you have
taught me that I cannot fail. Instead, help me to understand that failing is a
positive thing because it teaches me what not to do the next time around.
When you praise me for everything I do, even when it’s bad, you are teaching
me that I am perfect in everything that I do. When I finally discover that I am
not perfect, I will become confused. I may, then, strive to be perfect and that
will hurt me in the end. Or, I may give up on trying anything because I know it
can never be perfect. Please help me to understand that there is a big
difference between wanting to be perfect and working to perfect.
When you do everything for me, then try to understand that when you tell me to
leave your house, I may still be very needy because you have not taught me any
of the skills that I need to survive on my own.
When you buy me everything that I want, please remember that what I want
most is everything you can’t buy.
Everything that you do in front of me, teaches me how to be an adult. When
you lie about something, I learn that to lie is okay. When you fight with your
partner in front of me, I learn that to resolve arguments, it’s okay to fight. When
you are rude and inconsiderate to other people, I learn that being disrespectful is
normal. When you are never around, I learn that I’m not worth being around
and that makes me vulnerable to unhealthy relationships, ones that show me
attention, and you have taught me the kind of person to choose.
I really need to learn that all the concrete things, the tangible things, the
material things are, in fact, blessings. The most important things are those that
are abstract: love, faith, trust, belief, honour, empathy, mercy, wisdom,
compassion, courage, grace, humility, kindness, perseverance, sacrifice, self-control,
strength, tolerance, truth, hope. The only way I can understand these
abstract things is to have them clearly modeled by you, the most important adult
influences in my life.
Please, please talk to me; it’s the only way I will learn to listen.
Above all, know that I love you, and I am a most forgiving child. When you
mess up, talk to me about it, admit it. I will have great respect for you and
when you ask to be forgiven, I will forgive you, hug you, and love you as though
none of it had ever happened.
Obviously, Barb is not talking about neglect but, rather, the other extreme which is the tendency of modern-day parents to ‘over-manage’ their kids. Naturally, the consequences of over-managed kids at home carries over to the classroom and, for an unlucky minority of youth, into addiction treatment as well.
A Sense of Entitlement/Lack of Motivation
Clients who have been raised by over-managing parents often lack motivation. Why? Because motivation is not necessary when every need and threat is anticipated and dealt with beforehand by an overzealous parent. Over-managing has a debilitating effect on a child’s growth process. Since recovery from addiction is inherently a growth process, therapy cannot treat addiction without addressing entitlement.
Cathy Patterson-Sterling, Director of Family Services at Sunshine Coast, has written about entitlement in another article posted in this blog, “The Cost of Rescuing.”
Perfectionism
Clients who have been raised to think they can do no wrong are notoriously critical of others. As adults, clients learn to use perfectionism as a way of avoiding painful self-reflection by noticing the shortcomings of staff, their peers, the facility, the food, etc. Anything is fair game and keeps the client in his comfort zone.
Why Parents Over-Manage
In her article, The Gift of Adulthood, Cathy Patterson-Sterling finds that many parents who over-manage their kids do so out of fear. Fear can be a powerful emotion, often blinding parents to the negative consequences of their over-managing tendencies.
Fostering Resilience as an Alternative to Over-Managing
It may seem obvious that it is difficult for parents to remove all potential sources of pain, increasingly so as their children reach maturity. However, fear often makes it difficult for a parent to think rationally when they see their children suffering. Fortunately, there is research showing the effectiveness of fostering resilience – the positive capacity of people to cope with life’s challenges. * While resilience can’t prevent painful events from occurring, teaching children to courageously face life’s twists and turns does nurture personal growth.
(*) Note: Resilience has been extensively researched in psychology. A good book for parents is Raising Resilient Children: Fostering Strength, Hope, and Optimism in Your Child, written by Robert Brooks, Ph.D.
When All Else Fails, Role Model
Nearly half of Barb’s poem is dedicated to the importance of parents serving as good role models for their children. Fortunately, being a good role model is one of the few things over which we have control. If we look after ourselves, our kids tend to follow suit. In fact, when parents ask Cathy what is the best thing they can do to help their addicted sons, Cathy advises them to practice good self-care. Such advice may seem counter-intuitive but it is not when one remembers the replicative nature of role modeling.
PS
Speaking from personal experience, I recognize that there is a difference between over-parenting and over-scheduling. Growing up in Edmonton in the early 1970s, I don’t remember getting rides to school nor having so much structured leisure time. However, I don’t think this change is due to overzealous parenting so much as it is a response to the hectic pace of modern life.


Sunshine Coast Health Center is a provincially-approved drug and alcohol rehabilitation facility licensed by VCH
Sunshine Coast Health Center is an accredited health care provider with Accreditation Canada